Case 1
10 minutes in, people have not started speaking
IAF competency reference C
Create and Sustain a Participatory Environment
1. Read the situation
8 people, including some meeting for the first time, sit silently in front of the topic. Only the facilitator continues explaining the background.
- Only the facilitator is speaking
- The first contribution to the whole group carries a psychological burden
- 10 minutes after the start, no participant's voice has been recorded
2. Predict what comes next
If you keep asking questions to the whole group, who will speak first, and how will later contributions become uneven?
Input is not sent and is lost when you leave the page. Do not enter personal information or the names of real people.
3. Choose an intervention
4. Check the result and reasons
Without JavaScript, all three choice results are shown.
Result of choice A
Failure example: the explanation grows without checking understanding, and participants still do not know how to contribute.
Reason: This assumes that a lack of information is the main cause of silence, without reducing the burden of speaking for the first time.
Result of choice B (Recommended)
What happens: everyone has spoken once in a pair before briefly sharing the main points with the whole group.
Reason: Time to think alone and talk in pairs before speaking to the whole group reduces the burden of getting started in stages.
Result of choice C
Failure example: someone with higher status or more speaking experience breaks the silence, and their account tends to become the reference point.
Reason: Waiting alone does not change uneven opportunities to speak or the burden of contributing to the whole group.
Typical failure
The more the facilitator explains, the more participants see this as a place to hear the correct answer, making the first contribution even harder.
Recommendation for this case
Allow a short period of individual thinking, then talk in pairs, then bring just one brief contribution each to the whole group.
Reason: Thinking alone, talking in pairs, and then sharing with everyone lets all participants reach the sharing stage with an idea of their own.
Read 1-2-4-AllPractice pack: 15 minutes
A 15-minute rehearsal for the first contributions
- Two roles
- Facilitator / Participant and observer
- Rehearsal
- Ask ‘What would you like to take away today?’ and demonstrate 1 minute alone, 2 minutes in pairs, and 4 minutes in the whole group.
- Observe
- Seconds between reading the question and the first spoken contribution
- What prompts one person's contribution to pass to the next person
- The stage at which someone has still not spoken
- Debrief
- Which transition reduced the burden of speaking?
- How would you form groups for the actual number of participants?
- What to take away
- Record the session question, time for each stage, and grouping method on one sheet.
Try this briefly with two colleagues, not the actual session's participants. The organiser separately judges safety and suitability for the real session.
